| Year | Winner(s) | Work | Nominees | Ref. |
| 2010 | John Perez | "Empire State of Mind" (performed by Jay-Z featuring Alicia Keys) | - "Bad Romance" – Thomas Kloss (performed by Lady Gaga)
- "Dog Days Are Over" – Adam Frisch (performed by Florence and the Machine)
- "Little Lion Man" – Ben Magahy (performed by Mumford & Sons)
- "Not Afraid" – Christopher Probst (performed by Eminem)
| |
| 2011 | Tom Townend | "Rolling in the Deep" (performed by Adele) | - "Hurricane" – Benoît Debie, Jared Leto, Rob Witt and Daniel Carberry (performed by Thirty Seconds to Mars)
- "Love the Way You Lie" – Christopher Probst (performed by Eminem featuring Rihanna)
- "Run the World (Girls)" – Jeffrey Kimball (performed by Beyoncé)
- "Teenage Dream" – Paul Laufer (performed by Katy Perry)
| |
| 2012 | André Chemetoff | "Bad Girls" (performed by M.I.A.) | - "Born to Die" – André Chemetoff (performed by Lana Del Rey)
- "Princess of China" – Stéphane Vallée (performed by Coldplay featuring Rihanna)
- "Someone Like You" – David Johnson (performed by Adele)
- "Take Care" – Kasper Tuxen (performed by Drake featuring Rihanna)
| |
| 2013 | Ryan Lewis, Jason Koenig and Mego Lin | "Can't Hold Us" (performed by Macklemore and Ryan Lewis featuring Ray Dalton) | - "Ride" – Malik Sayeed (performed by Lana Del Rey)
- "Sacrilege" – Alexis Zabé (performed by Yeah Yeah Yeahs)
- "Tuna Melt" – TS Pfeffer and Robert McHugh (performed by A-Trak and Tommy Trash)
- "Up in the Air" – David Devlin (performed by Thirty Seconds to Mars)
| |
| 2014 | Darren Lew and Jackson Hunt | "Pretty Hurts" (performed by Beyoncé) | - "Afterlife" – Evan Prosofsky (performed by Arcade Fire)
- "City of Angels" – David Devlin (performed by Thirty Seconds to Mars)
- "Hate or Glory" – Michael Ragen (performed by Gesaffelstein)
- "West Coast" – Evan Prosofsky (performed by Lana Del Rey)
| |
| 2015 | Larkin Seiple | "Never Catch Me" (performed by Flying Lotus featuring Kendrick Lamar) | - "Bad Blood" – Christopher Probst (performed by Taylor Swift featuring Kendrick Lamar)
- "Left Hand Free" – Mike Simpson (performed by Alt-J)
- "Thinking Out Loud" – Daniel Pearl (performed by Ed Sheeran)
- "Two Weeks" – Justin Brown (performed by FKA Twigs)
| |
| 2016 | Malik Sayeed | "Formation" (performed by Beyoncé) | - "Hello" – André Turpin (performed by Adele)
- "I Wanna Know" – Corey Jennings (performed by Alesso)
- "Into You" – Paul Laufer (performed by Ariana Grande)
- "Lazarus" – Crille Forsberg (performed by David Bowie)
| |
| 2017 | Scott Cunningham | "HUMBLE." (performed by Kendrick Lamar) | - "Castle on the Hill" – Steve Annis (performed by Ed Sheeran)
- "Nobody Speak" – David Proctor (performed by DJ Shadow featuring Run the Jewels)
- "Now or Never" – Kristof Brandl (performed by Halsey)
- "Thunder" – Matthew Wise (performed by Imagine Dragons)
| |
| 2018 | Benoît Debie | "Apeshit" (performed by The Carters) | - "Growing Pains" – Pau Castejón (performed by Alessia Cara)
- "In My Blood" – Jonathan Sela (performed by Shawn Mendes)
- "No Tears Left to Cry" – Scott Cunningham (performed by Ariana Grande)
- "River" – Frank Mobilio and Patrick Meller (performed by Eminem featuring Ed Sheeran)
- "This is America" – Larkin Seiple (performed by Childish Gambino)
| |
| 2019 | Scott Cunningham | "Señorita" (performed by Shawn Mendes and Camila Cabello) | - "Almeda" – Chayse Irvin, Ryan Marie Helfant, and Justin Hamilton (performed by Solange)
- "hostage" – Pau Castejón (performed by Billie Eilish)
- "Me!" – Starr Whitesides (performed by Taylor Swift featuring Brendon Urie of Panic! at the Disco)
- "thank u, next" – Christopher Probst (performed by Ariana Grande)
- "Tints" – Elias Talbot (performed by Anderson .Paak featuring Kendrick Lamar)
| |