The Professional Footballers' Association Scotland Team of the Year (often called the PFA Scotland Team of the Year, or simply the Team of the Year) is an annual award given to a set of 44 footballers in the four national tiers of the Scottish football league system, who are seen to be deserving of being named in a "Team of the Year". The award is compiled by the members of the players' trade union, Professional Footballers' Association Scotland (PFA Scotland), with the winners then being voted for by the other players in their respective divisions. The award was instituted in the 2006–07 season. In that first season, the award was voted for by the managers in each division.
The award was expanded to include the Scottish Women's Premier League (SWPL) in 2021–22.
Key
Positions | GK | Goalkeeper |
| DF | Defender |
| MF | Midfielder |
| FW | Forward |
Key | Symbol | Meaning |
| † | Appeared in a first tier Team of the Year more than once |
| ‡ | Appeared in a second tier Team of the Year more than once |
| * | Appeared in a third tier Team of the Year more than once |
| ¤ | Appeared in a fourth tier Team of the Year more than once |
| Pos. | Position |
Winners
2006–07
- Sources
Premier League
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Artur Boruc | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Steven Whittaker | Hibernian | 1 |
| DF | Russell Anderson | Aberdeen | 1 |
| DF | Stephen McManus | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Lee Naylor | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Scott Brown | Hibernian | 1 |
| MF | Barry Ferguson | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Shunsuke Nakamura | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Steven Naismith | Kilmarnock | 1 |
| FW | Kris Boyd | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Scott McDonald | Motherwell | 1 |
First Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Alan Main | Gretna | 1 |
| DF | Martin Canning | Gretna | 1 |
| DF | Neil McGregor | Clyde | 1 |
| DF | Kevin James | St Johnstone | 1 |
| DF | Goran Stanic | St Johnstone | 1 |
| MF | Craig Bryson | Clyde | 1 |
| MF | Alex Rae | Dundee | 1 |
| MF | Don Cowie | Ross County | 1 |
| FW | Jason Scotland | St Johnstone | 1 |
| FW | Colin McMenamin | Gretna | 1 |
| FW | Mark Roberts | Partick Thistle | 1 |
Second Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Paul Mathers | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| DF | Peter Weatherson | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| DF | Stewart Greacen | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| DF | Todd Lumsden | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| DF | Ross Forsyth | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| MF | Jamie Stevenson | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| MF | Chris Aitken | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| MF | Kieran McAnespie | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Liam Buchanan | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| FW | Iain Russell | Brechin City | 1 |
| FW | Paul McGowan | Greenock Morton | 1 |
Third Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Stephen Grindlay | Dumbarton | 1 |
| DF | Paul Paton | Queen's Park | 1 |
| DF | Jonathon Smart | East Fife | 1 |
| DF | David Craig | Dumbarton | 1 |
| DF | Chris McGroarty | Berwick Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Stuart Kettlewell | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | Scott Chaplain | Albion Rovers | 1 |
| MF | Paul Stewart | East Stirlingshire | 1 |
| FW | Garry Wood | Berwick Rangers | 1 |
| FW | David Weatherston | Queen's Park | 1 |
| FW | Martin Johnston | Elgin City | 1 |
2007–08
Premier League
Barry Robson played for Dundee United from August 2007 until January 2008, when he transferred to Celtic.
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Artur Boruc † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Steven Whittaker † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | Carlos Cuéllar | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Gary Caldwell | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Saša Papac | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Barry Ferguson † | Rangers | 2 |
| MF | Barry Robson | Dundee United / Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Aiden McGeady | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Shunsuke Nakamura † | Celtic | 2 |
| FW | Scott McDonald † | Celtic | 2 |
| FW | Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink | Celtic | 1 |
2008–09
Premier League
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Allan McGregor | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Andreas Hinkel | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Madjid Bougherra | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Gary Caldwell † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Saša Papac † | Rangers | 2 |
| MF | Scott Brown † | Celtic | 2 |
| MF | Steven Davis | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Pedro Mendes | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Aiden McGeady † | Celtic | 2 |
| FW | Kenny Miller | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Scott McDonald † | Celtic | 3 |
2009–10
Premier League
Eight Rangers players were selected, along with Andy Webster, who was on loan to Dundee United from Rangers that season.
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Allan McGregor † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | Steven Whittaker † | Rangers | 3 |
| DF | David Weir | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Andy Webster | Dundee United | 1 |
| DF | Saša Papac † | Rangers | 3 |
| MF | Jim O'Brien | Motherwell | 1 |
| MF | Steven Davis † | Rangers | 2 |
| MF | Liam Miller | Hibernian | 1 |
| MF | Lee McCulloch | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Kenny Miller † | Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Kris Boyd † | Rangers | 2 |
2010–11
- Source
Premier League
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Allan McGregor † | Rangers | 3 |
| DF | Mark Wilson | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Marius Žaliūkas | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Madjid Bougherra † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | Emilio Izaguirre | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Steven Naismith † | Rangers | 2 |
| MF | Beram Kayal | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Alexei Eremenko | Kilmarnock | 1 |
| FW | David Goodwillie | Dundee United | 1 |
| FW | Conor Sammon | Kilmarnock | 1 |
| FW | Gary Hooper | Celtic | 1 |
2011–12
- Sources
Premier League
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Darren Randolph | Motherwell | 1 |
| DF | Adam Matthews | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Gavin Gunning | Dundee United | 1 |
| DF | Charlie Mulgrew | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Paul Dixon | Dundee United | 1 |
| MF | James Forrest | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Steven Davis † | Rangers | 3 |
| MF | Gary Mackay-Steven | Dundee United | 1 |
| FW | Johnny Russell | Dundee United | 1 |
| FW | Jon Daly | Dundee United | 1 |
| FW | Gary Hooper † | Celtic | 2 |
First Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Michael McGovern | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Kieran Duffie | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Scott Boyd | Ross County | 1 |
| DF | Grant Munro | Ross County | 1 |
| DF | Aaron Taylor-Sinclair | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Nicky Riley | Dundee | 1 |
| MF | Mark Millar | Falkirk | 1 |
| MF | Ryan Conroy | Dundee | 1 |
| FW | Michael Gardyne | Ross County | 1 |
| FW | Farid El Alagui | Falkirk | 1 |
| FW | Colin McMenamin ‡ | Ross County | 2 |
Second Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Stephen Grindlay | Dumbarton | 1 |
| DF | Mark Baxter | Arbroath | 1 |
| DF | Joe Mbu | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| DF | John Armstrong | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| DF | Kenny Adamson | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| MF | Josh Falkingham | Arbroath | 1 |
| MF | Jon Robertson | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| MF | Scott Agnew | Dumbarton | 1 |
| FW | Ryan Donnelly | Airdrie United | 1 |
| FW | Steven Doris | Arbroath | 1 |
| FW | Ryan Wallace | East Fife | 1 |
Third Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Scott Bain | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Michael Doyle | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Ricky Little | Queen's Park | 1 |
| DF | Ryan Harding | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Daryll Meggatt | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | Ryan McCord | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Stephen Stirling | Stranraer | 1 |
| MF | Daniel Moore | Elgin City | 1 |
| FW | Jamie Longworth | Queen's Park | 1 |
| FW | Stevie May | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Kevin Cawley | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
2012–13
- Source
Premier League
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Darren Randolph † | Motherwell | 2 |
| DF | Adam Matthews † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Shaun Hutchinson | Motherwell | 1 |
| DF | Kelvin Wilson | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Charlie Mulgrew † | Celtic | 2 |
| MF | Andrew Shinnie | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Victor Wanyama | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Nicky Law | Motherwell | 1 |
| FW | Niall McGinn | Aberdeen | 1 |
| FW | Michael Higdon | Motherwell | 1 |
| FW | Leigh Griffiths | Hibernian | 1 |
First Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Scott Fox | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Stephen O'Donnell | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Jordan McMillan | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Callum Morris | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Aaron Taylor-Sinclair ‡ | Partick Thistle | 2 |
| MF | Stefan Scougall | Livingston | 1 |
| MF | Michael Tidser | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| MF | Stuart Bannigan | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| FW | Brian Graham | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| FW | Lyle Taylor | Falkirk | 1 |
| FW | Chris Erskine | Partick Thistle | 1 |
Second Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Lee Robinson | Queen of the South | 1 |
| DF | Chris Mitchell | Queen of the South | 1 |
| DF | Mark Durnan | Queen of the South | 1 |
| DF | Ben Gordon | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Chris Higgins | Queen of the South | 1 |
| MF | Alan Trouten | Brechin City | 1 |
| MF | Ryan McCord | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Daniel Carmichael | Queen of the South | 1 |
| FW | Andy Jackson | Brechin City | 1 |
| FW | Nicky Clark | Queen of the South | 1 |
| FW | Steven Doris * | Arbroath | 2 |
Third Division
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Jamie Barclay | Clyde | 1 |
| DF | Stephen McNally | Montrose | 1 |
| DF | Ricky Little ¤ | Queen's Park | 2 |
| DF | Lee McCulloch | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Lee Wallace | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Lee Currie | Berwick Rangers | 1 |
| MF | David Anderson | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | Daniel Moore ¤ | Elgin City | 2 |
| FW | Andrew Little | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Rory McAllister | Peterhead | 1 |
| FW | David Templeton | Rangers | 1 |
2013–14
- Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Fraser Forster | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Graeme Shinnie | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Virgil van Dijk | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Mark Reynolds | Aberdeen | 1 |
| DF | Andy Robertson | Dundee United | 1 |
| MF | Stuart Armstrong | Dundee United | 1 |
| MF | Peter Pawlett | Aberdeen | 1 |
| MF | Kris Commons | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Stevie May | St Johnstone | 1 |
| FW | Kris Boyd † | Kilmarnock | 3 |
| FW | Nadir Ciftci | Dundee United | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Michael McGovern ‡ | Falkirk | 2 |
| DF | Paul McGinn | Dumbarton | 1 |
| DF | Will Vaulks | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Stephen Kingsley | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Ziggy Gordon | Hamilton Academical | 1 |
| MF | Tony Andreu | Hamilton Academical | 1 |
| MF | Mark Millar ‡ | Falkirk | 2 |
| MF | Ali Crawford | Hamilton Academical | 1 |
| FW | Rory Loy | Falkirk | 1 |
| FW | Kane Hemmings | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| FW | Peter MacDonald | Dundee | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Cammy Bell | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Ryan Williamson | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Callum Morris | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Lee McCulloch | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Lee Wallace | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Andy Stirling | Stranraer | 1 |
| MF | Andy Geggan | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Nicky Law | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Michael Moffat | Ayr United | 1 |
| FW | Jon Daly | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Gavin Swankie | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Graeme Smith | Peterhead | 1 |
| DF | Devon Jacobs | Berwick Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Steven Noble | Peterhead | 1 |
| DF | Michael Dunlop | Albion Rovers | 1 |
| DF | Kieran MacDonald | Clyde | 1 |
| MF | Blair Spittal | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | David Anderson ¤ | Queen's Park | 2 |
| MF | Lee Currie ¤ | Berwick Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Kenny MacKay | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Rory McAllister | Peterhead | 2 |
| FW | Andy Rodgers | Peterhead | 1 |
2014–15
Sources
Premiership
Stuart Armstrong played for Dundee United from August 2014 until February 2015, when he transferred to Celtic.
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Craig Gordon | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Shay Logan | Aberdeen | 1 |
| DF | Jason Denayer | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Virgil van Dijk † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Graeme Shinnie † | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 2 |
| MF | Stuart Armstrong † | Dundee United / Celtic | 2 |
| MF | Scott Brown † | Celtic | 3 |
| MF | Stefan Johansen | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Nadir Çiftçi † | Dundee United | 2 |
| FW | Adam Rooney | Aberdeen | 1 |
| FW | Greg Stewart | Dundee | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Neil Alexander | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | David Gray | Hibernian | 1 |
| DF | Alim Öztürk | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Danny Wilson | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Lewis Stevenson | Hibernian | 1 |
| MF | Scott Allan | Hibernian | 1 |
| MF | Morgaro Gomis | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| MF | Jamie Walker | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| FW | Gavin Reilly | Queen of the South | 1 |
| FW | Rory Loy ‡ | Falkirk | 2 |
| FW | Osman Sow | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Rab Douglas | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Mark Russell | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| DF | Stuart Malcolm | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Frank McKeown | Stranraer | 1 |
| DF | Paddy Boyle | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| MF | Alan Trouten * | Brechin City | 2 |
| MF | Jamie Stevenson * | Peterhead | 2 |
| MF | Willie Gibson | Stranraer | 1 |
| FW | Gavin Swankie * | Forfar Athletic | 2 |
| FW | Declan McManus | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| FW | Bobby Barr | Brechin City | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Neil Parry | Albion Rovers | 1 |
| DF | Shaun Rooney | Queen's Park | 1 |
| DF | Michael Dunlop ¤ | Albion Rovers | 2 |
| DF | Marvin Andrews | Montrose | 1 |
| DF | Ross Dunlop | Albion Rovers | 1 |
| MF | Bobby Linn | Arbroath | 1 |
| MF | Darren Miller | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | Paul Woods | Queen's Park | 1 |
| FW | Shane Sutherland | Elgin City | 1 |
| FW | Peter Weatherson | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Simon Murray | Arbroath | 1 |
2015–16
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Scott Bain | Dundee | 1 |
| DF | Shay Logan † | Aberdeen | 2 |
| DF | Alim Öztürk | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Andrew Davies | Ross County | 1 |
| DF | Kieran Tierney | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Jonny Hayes | Aberdeen | 1 |
| MF | Kenny McLean | Aberdeen | 1 |
| MF | Graeme Shinnie † | Aberdeen | 3 |
| FW | Kane Hemmings | Dundee | 1 |
| FW | Leigh Griffiths † | Celtic | 2 |
| FW | Greg Stewart † | Dundee | 2 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Danny Rogers | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | James Tavernier | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Darren McGregor | Hibernian | 1 |
| DF | Peter Grant | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Lee Wallace | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Jason Holt | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | John McGinn | Hibernian | 1 |
| MF | Barrie McKay | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | John Baird | Falkirk | 1 |
| FW | Martyn Waghorn | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Jason Cummings | Hibernian | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Graeme Smith | Peterhead | 1 |
| DF | Nicky Devlin | Ayr United | 1 |
| DF | Michael Dunlop | Albion Rovers | 1 |
| DF | Ben Richards-Everton | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Paddy Boyle * | Ayr United | 2 |
| MF | Liam Watt | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| MF | Andy Geggan * | Dunfermline Athletic | 2 |
| MF | Joe Cardle | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Greig Spence | Cowdenbeath | 1 |
| FW | Rory McAllister | Peterhead | 1 |
| FW | Faissal El Bakhtaoui | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Chris Smith | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| DF | Ricky Little ¤ | Arbroath | 3 |
| DF | Jonathan Page | East Fife | 1 |
| DF | Gary Naysmith | East Fife | 1 |
| DF | Scott Linton | Clyde | 1 |
| MF | Matty Flynn | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Kyle Wilkie | East Fife | 1 |
| MF | Bobby Linn ¤ | Arbroath | 2 |
| FW | Peter Weatherson ¤ | Annan Athletic | 2 |
| FW | Nathan Austin | East Fife | 1 |
| FW | Craig Gunn | Elgin City | 1 |
2016–17
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Joe Lewis | Aberdeen | 1 |
| DF | Shay Logan † | Aberdeen | 3 |
| DF | Mikael Lustig | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Liam Lindsay | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Kieran Tierney † | Celtic | 2 |
| MF | Stuart Armstrong † | Celtic | 3 |
| MF | Scott Brown † | Celtic | 4 |
| MF | Kenny McLean † | Aberdeen | 2 |
| FW | Jonny Hayes † | Aberdeen | 2 |
| FW | Moussa Dembélé | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Scott Sinclair | Celtic | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Cammy Bell | Dundee United | 1 |
| DF | Nicky Devlin | Ayr United | 1 |
| DF | Darren McGregor ‡ | Hibernian | 2 |
| DF | Thomas O'Ware | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| DF | Lewis Stevenson ‡ | Hibernian | 2 |
| MF | Stevie Mallan | St Mirren | 1 |
| MF | John McGinn ‡ | Hibernian | 2 |
| MF | Ross Forbes | Greenock Morton | 1 |
| FW | Tony Andreu ‡ | Dundee United | 2 |
| FW | Stephen Dobbie | Queen of the South | 1 |
| FW | Jason Cummings ‡ | Hibernian | 2 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Neil Parry | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Ryan McGeever | Queen's Park | 1 |
| DF | Andy Graham | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Jonathan Page | East Fife | 1 |
| DF | Calum Waters | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Scott Pittman | Livingston | 1 |
| MF | Shaun Byrne | Livingston | 1 |
| MF | Jordan Kirkpatrick | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Andy Ryan | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| FW | Liam Buchanan * | Livingston | 2 |
| FW | Danny Mullen | Livingston | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Chris Smith ¤ | Stirling Albion | 2 |
| DF | Ricky Little ¤ | Arbroath | 4 |
| DF | Thomas O'Brien | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Colin Hamilton | Arbroath | 1 |
| DF | Archie MacPhee | Elgin City | 1 |
| MF | Brian Cameron | Elgin City | 1 |
| MF | Thomas Reilly | Elgin City | 1 |
| MF | Bobby Linn ¤ | Arbroath | 3 |
| FW | Steven Doris | Arbroath | 1 |
| FW | Shane Sutherland ¤ | Elgin City | 2 |
| FW | Peter MacDonald | Clyde | 1 |
2017–18
Sources
Premiership
[citation needed]
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Jon McLaughlin | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | James Tavernier | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Christophe Berra | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Scott McKenna | Aberdeen | 1 |
| DF | Kieran Tierney † | Celtic | 3 |
| MF | James Forrest † | Celtic | 2 |
| MF | John McGinn | Hibernian | 1 |
| MF | Scott Brown † | Celtic | 5 |
| MF | Dylan McGeouch | Hibernian | 1 |
| FW | Jordan Jones | Kilmarnock | 1 |
| FW | Kris Boyd † | Kilmarnock | 4 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Neil Alexander ‡ | Livingston | 2 |
| DF | Ryan Williamson | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Craig Halkett | Livingston | 1 |
| DF | Thomas O'Ware ‡ | Greenock Morton | 2 |
| DF | Liam Smith | St Mirren | 1 |
| MF | Cammy Smith | St Mirren | 1 |
| MF | Stephen McGinn | St Mirren | 1 |
| MF | Iain Vigurs | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Gavin Reilly ‡ | St Mirren | 2 |
| FW | Stephen Dobbie ‡ | Queen of the South | 2 |
| FW | Lewis Morgan | St Mirren | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Neil Parry * | Alloa Athletic | 2 |
| DF | Scott Taggart | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Iain Davidson | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| DF | Thomas O'Brien | Arbroath | 1 |
| DF | Jason Thomson | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| MF | Declan McDaid | Ayr United | 1 |
| MF | Lewis Vaughan | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| MF | Iain Flannigan | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Michael Moffat * | Ayr United | 2 |
| FW | Lawrence Shankland | Ayr United | 1 |
| FW | Alan Trouten * | Albion Rovers | 3 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Greg Fleming | Peterhead | 1 |
| DF | Jason Brown | Peterhead | 1 |
| DF | David McCracken | Peterhead | 1 |
| DF | Seán Dillon | Montrose | 1 |
| DF | Andrew Steeves | Montrose | 1 |
| MF | Harry Paton | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| MF | Thomas Reilly ¤ | Elgin City | 2 |
| MF | Willie Gibson | Peterhead | 1 |
| FW | Mark McGuigan | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| FW | Rory McAllister ¤ | Peterhead | 3 |
| FW | Darren Smith | Stirling Albion | 1 |
2018–19
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Allan McGregor † | Rangers | 4 |
| DF | James Tavernier † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | Kristoffer Ajer | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Dedryck Boyata | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Craig Halkett | Livingston | 1 |
| MF | James Forrest † | Celtic | 3 |
| MF | Callum McGregor | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Scott Brown † | Celtic | 6 |
| MF | Graeme Shinnie † | Aberdeen | 4 |
| FW | Alfredo Morelos | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Ryan Kent | Rangers | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Scott Fox ‡ | Ross County | 2 |
| DF | Marcus Fraser | Ross County | 1 |
| DF | Andy Graham | Alloa Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Michael Rose | Ayr United | 1 |
| DF | Liam Smith ‡ | Ayr United | 2 |
| MF | Aaron Doran | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Liam Polworth | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Jamie Lindsay | Ross County | 1 |
| FW | Michael Gardyne ‡ | Ross County | 2 |
| FW | Stephen Dobbie ‡ | Queen of the South | 3 |
| FW | Lawrence Shankland | Ayr United | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Marc McCallum | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Jason Thomson * | Arbroath | 2 |
| DF | Ricky Little | Arbroath | 1 |
| DF | Thomas O'Brien * | Arbroath | 2 |
| DF | Euan Murray | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| MF | Bobby Linn | Arbroath | 1 |
| MF | Dale Hilson | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Gavin Swankie * | Arbroath | 3 |
| MF | Dom Thomas | Dumbarton | 1 |
| FW | Kevin Nisbet | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| FW | John Baird | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Blair Currie | Clyde | 1 |
| DF | Craig Thomson | Edinburgh City | 1 |
| DF | Conrad Balatoni | Edinburgh City | 1 |
| DF | Martin McNiff | Clyde | 1 |
| DF | Jamie Stevenson | Peterhead | 1 |
| MF | Willie Gibson ¤ | Peterhead | 2 |
| MF | Scott Brown | Peterhead | 1 |
| MF | John Rankin | Clyde | 1 |
| MF | Chris Johnston | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| FW | David Goodwillie | Clyde | 1 |
| FW | Blair Henderson | Edinburgh City | 1 |
2019–20
Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, PFA Scotland cancelled their awards for the 2019–20 season.
2020–21
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Allan McGregor † | Rangers | 5 |
| DF | James Tavernier † | Rangers | 3 |
| DF | Kristoffer Ajer † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Connor Goldson | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Borna Barišić | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Glen Kamara | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | David Turnbull | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Steven Davis † | Rangers | 4 |
| FW | Odsonne Edouard | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Alfredo Morelos † | Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Ryan Kent † | Rangers | 2 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Craig Gordon | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Michael Smith | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Euan Murray | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Ayo Obileye | Queen of the South | 1 |
| DF | Lee Ashcroft | Dundee | 1 |
| MF | Charlie Adam | Dundee | 1 |
| MF | Regan Hendry | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| MF | Andy Irving | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| FW | Connor Shields | Queen of the South | 1 |
| FW | Liam Boyce | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| FW | Nikolay Todorov | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
2021–22
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Craig Gordon † | Heart of Midlothian | 2 |
| DF | James Tavernier † | Rangers | 4 |
| DF | Cameron Carter-Vickers | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | John Souttar | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Josip Juranović | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Tom Rogic | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Callum McGregor † | Celtic | 2 |
| MF | Regan Charles-Cook | Ross County | 1 |
| FW | Jota | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Alfredo Morelos † | Rangers | 3 |
| FW | Kyogo Furuhashi | Celtic | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Zach Hemming | Kilmarnock | 1 |
| DF | Ricky Little | Arbroath | 1 |
| DF | Lewis Mayo | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Robbie Deas | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Kevin Holt | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Fraser Murray | Kilmarnock | 1 |
| MF | Michael McKenna | Arbroath | 1 |
| MF | Scott Tiffoney | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| FW | Billy Mckay | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| FW | Brian Graham ‡ | Partick Thistle | 2 |
| FW | Kyle Lafferty | Kilmarnock | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Stuart McKenzie | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Cammy Ballantyne | Montrose | 1 |
| DF | Callum Fordyce | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| DF | Morgyn Neill | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Harry Milne | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Blair Yule | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Fraser Fyvie | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Adam Frizzell | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| FW | Mitch Megginson | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Rory McAllister * | Cove Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Dylan Easton | Airdrieonians | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Darren Jamieson | Kelty Hearts | 1 |
| DF | Ross Meechan | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Andy Munro | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Thomas O'Ware | Kelty Hearts | 1 |
| DF | Jordon Forster | Kelty Hearts | 1 |
| MF | Jamie Barjonas | Kelty Hearts | 1 |
| MF | Owen Moxon | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Joe Cardle | Kelty Hearts | 1 |
| FW | Thomas Orr | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| FW | Nathan Austin ¤ | Kelty Hearts | 2 |
| FW | Kane Hester | Elgin City | 1 |
SWPL
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Lee Alexander | Glasgow City | 1 |
| DF | Jenna Clark | Glasgow City | 1 |
| DF | Caitlin Hayes | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Chloe Craig | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Nicola Docherty | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Hayley Lauder | Glasgow City | 1 |
| MF | Sammy Kerr | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Colette Cavanagh | Hibernian | 1 |
| FW | Lizzie Arnot | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Priscila Chinchilla | Glasgow City | 1 |
| FW | Charlie Wellings | Celtic | 1 |
2022–23
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Joe Hart | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | James Tavernier † | Rangers | 5 |
| DF | Cameron Carter-Vickers † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Carl Starfelt | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Greg Taylor | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | Malik Tillman | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Callum McGregor † | Celtic | 3 |
| MF | Reo Hatate | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Luis Lopes | Aberdeen | 1 |
| FW | Kyogo Furuhashi † | Celtic | 2 |
| FW | Kevin van Veen | Motherwell | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Calum Ferrie | Queen's Park | 2 |
| DF | Lee Ashcroft ‡ | Dundee | 2 |
| DF | Thomas O'Brien | Arbroath | 1 |
| DF | Ryan Sweeney | Dundee | 1 |
| DF | Harry Milne | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Grant Savoury | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | Malachi Boateng | Queen's Park | 1 |
| MF | Lyall Cameron | Dundee | 1 |
| FW | Dipo Akinyemi | Ayr United | 1 |
| FW | Brian Graham ‡ | Partick Thistle | 3 |
| FW | Dom Thomas | Queen's Park | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Deniz Mehmet | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Cammy Ballantyne * | Airdrieonians | 2 |
| DF | Kyle Benedictus | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| DF | Callum Fordyce * | Airdrieonians | 2 |
| DF | Josh Edwards | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Adam Frizzell * | Airdrieonians | 2 |
| MF | Matthew Todd | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Aidan Nesbitt | Falkirk | 1 |
| FW | Ruari Paton | Queen of the South | 1 |
| FW | Callum Gallagher | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| FW | Callumn Morrison | Falkirk | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Blair Currie ¤ | Stirling Albion | 2 |
| DF | Ross McGeachie | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| DF | Andy Munro ¤ | Forfar Athletic | 2 |
| DF | Gregor Buchanan | Dumbarton | 1 |
| DF | Paul McLean | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| MF | Reece Lyon | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Craig Slater | Forfar Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Jack Leitch | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| FW | Dale Carrick | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| FW | Tommy Goss | Annan Athletic | 1 |
| FW | Charlie Reilly | Albion Rovers | 1 |
SWPL
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Lee Gibson † | Glasgow City | 2 |
| DF | Rachel McLauchlan | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | Caitlin Hayes † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Jenna Clark † | Glasgow City | 2 |
| DF | Emma Brownlie | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| MF | Mairead Fulton | Glasgow City | 1 |
| MF | Ciara Grant | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| MF | Sam Kerr † | Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Brogan Hay | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Lauren Davidson | Glasgow City | 1 |
| FW | Jacynta Galabadaarachchi | Celtic | 1 |
2023–24
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Jack Butland | Rangers | 1 |
| DF | James Tavernier † | Rangers | 6 |
| DF | Cameron Carter-Vickers † | Celtic | 3 |
| DF | Liam Scales | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Owen Beck | Dundee | 1 |
| MF | Matt O'Riley | Celtic | 1 |
| MF | John Lundstram | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Callum McGregor † | Celtic | 4 |
| FW | Bojan Miovski | Aberdeen | 1 |
| FW | Lawrence Shankland | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| FW | Theo Bair | Motherwell | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Calum Ferrie ‡ | Queen's Park | 2 |
| DF | Jack McMillan | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Kevin Holt ‡ | Dundee United | 2 |
| DF | Scott McMann | Dundee United | 1 |
| DF | Josh Edwards | Dunfermline Athletic | 1 |
| MF | Adam Frizzell | Airdrieonians | 1 |
| MF | Craig Sibbald | Dundee United | 1 |
| MF | Sam Stanton | Raith Rovers | 1 |
| FW | Louis Moult | Dundee United | 1 |
| FW | Brian Graham ‡ | Partick Thistle | 4 |
| FW | Ruari Paton | Queen's Park | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Nicky Hogarth | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Finn Yeats | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Coll Donaldson | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Tom Lang | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Leon McCann | Falkirk | 1 |
| MF | Brad Spencer | Falkirk | 1 |
| MF | Liam Henderson | Falkirk | 1 |
| MF | Aidan Nesbitt * | Falkirk | 2 |
| FW | Callumn Morrison * | Falkirk | 2 |
| FW | Rumarn Burrell | Cove Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Calvin Miller | Falkirk | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Darren Jamieson ¤ | Stenhousemuir | 2 |
| DF | Carlo Pignatiello | Dumbarton | 1 |
| DF | Nicky Jamieson | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| DF | Gregor Buchanan ¤ | Stenhousemuir | 2 |
| DF | Neil Martyniuk | Bonnyrigg Rose | 1 |
| MF | James Craigen | The Spartans | 1 |
| MF | Nat Wedderburn | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| MF | Andrew McCarthy | Peterhead | 1 |
| FW | Matty Aitken | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| FW | Blair Henderson ¤ | The Spartans | 2 |
| FW | Nathan Austin ¤ | East Fife | 3 |
SWPL
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Charlotte Parker-Smith | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| DF | Caitlin Hayes † | Celtic | 3 |
| DF | Nicola Docherty † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | Leah Eddie | Hibernian | 1 |
| DF | Emma Lawton | Partick Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Kirsty Maclean | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Rachel Rowe | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Katie Lockwood | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| FW | Amy Gallacher | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Jorian Baucom | Hibernian | 1 |
| FW | Rio Hardy | Rangers | 1 |
2024–25
Sources
Premiership
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Kasper Schmeichel | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Alistair Johnston | Celtic | 1 |
| DF | Cameron Carter-Vickers † | Celtic | 4 |
| DF | John Souttar † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | James Penrice | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| MF | Nicolas Raskin | Rangers | 1 |
| MF | Reo Hatate † | Celtic | 2 |
| MF | Callum McGregor † | Celtic | 5 |
| FW | Nicolas Kuhn | Celtic | 1 |
| FW | Sam Dalby | Dundee United | 1 |
| FW | Daizen Maeda | Celtic | 1 |
Championship
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Jérôme Prior | Livingston | 1 |
| DF | Keelan Adams | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Ryan McGowan | Livingston | 1 |
| DF | Liam Henderson | Falkirk | 1 |
| DF | Scott McMann ‡ | Ayr United | 2 |
| MF | Jamie Brandon | Livingston | 1 |
| MF | Brad Spencer | Falkirk | 1 |
| MF | Ben Dempsey | Ayr United | 1 |
| FW | Robbie Muirhead | Livingston | 1 |
| FW | George Oakley | Ayr United | 1 |
| FW | Calvin Miller | Falkirk | 1 |
League One
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Musa Dibaga | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| DF | Scott Taggart * | Alloa Athletic | 2 |
| DF | Gregor Buchanan | Stenhousemuir | 1 |
| DF | Thomas O'Brien * | Arbroath | 3 |
| DF | Danny Devine | Inverness Caledonian Thistle | 1 |
| MF | Ross Cunningham | Kelty Hearts | 1 |
| MF | Fraser Taylor | Arbroath | 1 |
| MF | Fraser Fyvie * | Cove Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Scott Stewart | Arbroath | 1 |
| FW | Mitch Megginson * | Cove Rangers | 2 |
| FW | Alfie Bavidge | Inverness CT | 1 |
League Two
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Liam McFarlane | East Fife | 1 |
| DF | Craig Ross | Stranraer | 1 |
| DF | Andy Munro ¤ | East Fife | 3 |
| DF | Brian Easton | East Fife | 1 |
| DF | Cieran Dunne | Peterhead | 1 |
| MF | Andrew McCarthy ¤ | Peterhead | 2 |
| MF | Innes Lawson | Edinburgh City | 1 |
| MF | Adam Brown | Stirling Albion | 1 |
| FW | Alan Trouten | East Fife | 1 |
| FW | Kieran Shanks | Peterhead | 1 |
| FW | Nathan Austin ¤ | East Fife | 4 |
SWPL
| Pos. | Player | Club | Appearance |
| GK | Erin Clachers | Hibernian | 1 |
| DF | Emma Lawton † | Celtic | 2 |
| DF | Samantha van Diemen | Glasgow City | 1 |
| DF | Leah Eddie † | Rangers | 2 |
| DF | Erin Husband | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| MF | Kirsty Maclean † | Rangers | 2 |
| MF | Eilidh Shore | Heart of Midlothian | 1 |
| MF | Aleigh Gambone | Glasgow City | 1 |
| FW | Eilidh Adams | Hibernian | 1 |
| FW | Katie Wilkinson | Rangers | 1 |
| FW | Brenna Lovera | Glasgow City | 1 |
- For more information, see Formation (association football).